Short description: Legal requirements of survey and designs of water projects.
Introduction - Legal requirements
Project committees, land agreement, by-laws, registration certificate
A community that would like to construct a new water project or to rehabilitate an existing water project must elect a Project Committee consisting of a Chairperson, a Secretary, a Treasurer as well as a deputy for each of these three persons. Other committee members should be the local Chief, an officer from the MoSD and an engineer or technician from the MoW or the WSB.
Preferably, the Chairperson should be a village elder who is experienced in handling meetings and solving human conflicts. The Secretary is usually a teacher who is conversant with English and office work. The Treasurer is often a business woman who is respected for her handling of money and bank matters.
It is usually beneficial if the local Member of Parliament (MP) or Councilor can be the project's Patron, mainly because MPs distribute large funds from the Constituency Development Fund (CDF) for development projects.
A Land Agreement for a community water project is also required by the MoSD before a Registration Certificate can be produced.
The agreement must state that the owners of the land in question agree that the land will be used for a community water project and its access road has been declared public land that can be used freely by the project members for drawing water.
Often it may take considerable time and, perhaps payments, to obtain such an agreement but it must be obtained to prevent the owners, or their descendants, from claiming the project being their private property at a later stage.
By-laws and Land Agreement are presented to the MoSD for their approval.
The By-law for a proposed water project consists of rules and conditions which the members have agreed upon for construction and management of their water project. An MoSD Officer, who is a committee member, can assist with writing the By-laws along the following guidelines:
1. Name of the project and where it is located near a village in sub-location, location, postal address, mobile numbers.
2. Type of water project and its capacity of supplying water.
3. Number of households to benefit from the water project.
4. Conditions for becoming a member of the project.
5. Duties of the members and committee members.
6. Elections, voting and quorum requirements.
In most cases a By-law is written by hand on some pages of A4 paper and stamped by the local Chief.
A Registration Certificate is issued to an approved community group.
The certificate allows the community to seek financial assistance from e.g. the CDF, the local WSB, a Non-governmental Organization (NGO), a bilateral donor, such as Danida or Sida, or an UN organization, such as UNICEF, FAO, ILO, etc.
Site evaluation reports
In most cases, the Client will give the highest priority to finding sites for hand dug wells along seasonal riverbeds or in shallow ground water because they are the most cost efficient water sources. In areas without suitable riverbeds and shallow water tables, the Client may give the second priority to harvesting rainwater from roads into either small earth dams or ground tanks. Where large roofs are available, such as at schools and hospitals, the best option, although expensive, may be gutters and
Survey and design
Where a well is proposed in a river bed, the Surveyor will be contracted to carry out a detailed survey with probing of the selected stretch of the riverbed.
Plan and profiles of a probed riverbed
The probing data is used for drawing the plan and profile of the riverbed to show the best place to sink a well and to perhaps build a subsurface dam. Survey reports should contain all measurements taken at the site as well as analyses of water, sand and soil. These data combined with rainfall data will determine the expected yield of water from the structure.
Design drawing for a hand dug well
Design drawings are made by adapting computerized standard drawings to the specific site conditions.
MoW requires 5 sets of drawings of the probing and designs in A2 format.
MoW, WSB, WRMA and NEMA stamp and sign the drawings when they are approved. One of these copies is returned to the Client as the permit to construct the structure.
Bills of quantities
Design drawings are used by a Quantity Surveyor to calculate the labour, tools and building material required for the construction work. However, for small structures, such a hand dug well built according to a standard design, the standard BQ for an 8 metres deep hand dug well with a bucket lift, can be used to estimate BQs for other hand dug wells by dividing this BQ with the depth of 8 metres and multiplying that figure with the depth in metres of any other well.
Should a hand or motor pump be preferred instead of the bucket lift, then the difference in cost is added.
BQs are used to calculate the construction cost of structures, such as a hand dug well, in order to estimate a realistic budget, which must be part of any Project Proposal. The best method to establish the construction cost of a structure is to photocopy a BQ and give a copy of it to each of at least three contractors and 3 suppliers of materials while asking them to give a quotation. To prevent over-pricing and cheating it is important that the contractors and hard ware owners do not know who else are giving quotations. When comparing quotations it is also important to consider issues such as delivery time, delivery capacity, warranties, qualities, down payments and final payments, because the cheapest quotation may turn out to be not the cheapest after all.
Tenders are used instead of quotations for large and complicated structures to be constructed by governmental and other organizations. Advertisements for tenders are published in the daily newspapers to invite qualified contractors and suppliers to collect tender documents at a small cost from the Clients offices within a certain period.
Tender documents contain among other subjects, design drawings, BQs, implementation schedule, place of construction site, documentation of similar projects implemented successfully, CVs of personnel, budget frame, time frame, etc.
Firms interested in presenting a bid (a tender) will obtain quotations from sub-contractors and suppliers as well as estimate the cost of personnel, transport equipment, etc. A detailed budget and logistical framework must also be included in a tender document. Bids are separated into two parts; a Project Proposal without budget and a Budget without project proposal.
Each part is placed in a separate and sealed envelope marked Project Proposal and Budget respectively. These two envelopes are then placed in one envelope marked with the name and details of the tender and handed over to the Clients office before a specific deadline. At a certain time and date, a Tender Committee consisting of experts invited by the Client will open the received bids and divide the envelopes into two piles; one with the envelopes marked Project Proposals and the other with the envelopes marked Budgets.
Tender Committees will spend a few days studying first the Project Proposals and each member will give his/her marks for the viability of each of the Project Proposals. Thereafter the envelopes with the Budgets will be opened, studied and marked by each member. The most ideal bid is found by comparing these two set of marks and a contract is formulated with the successful bidder. Working time and other expenditures spent on giving bids cannot be paid for.
The construction works can now be started!
Information Source Links
- Nissen-Petersen, E., W. Wanjihia, C. (2006). Water Surveys and Designs. Explains survey techniques and gives standard designs with average costs on water supply structures. Danish International Development Assistance (DANIDA)